The South Dakota Supreme Courtroom has upheld a decrease courtroom’s ruling that nullified a voter-passed modification to the state structure that will have legalized leisure marijuana use. Right here, a hashish plant on the Greenleaf Medical Hashish facility in Richmond, Va., in June.
Steve Helber/AP
cover caption
toggle caption
Steve Helber/AP
The South Dakota Supreme Courtroom has upheld a decrease courtroom’s ruling that nullified a voter-passed modification to the state structure that will have legalized leisure marijuana use. Right here, a hashish plant on the Greenleaf Medical Hashish facility in Richmond, Va., in June.
Steve Helber/AP
SIOUX FALLS, S.D. — The South Dakota Supreme Courtroom on Wednesday upheld a decrease courtroom’s ruling that nullified a voter-passed modification to the state structure that will have legalized leisure marijuana use.
Gov. Kristi Noem instigated the authorized struggle to strike down the modification passed by voters in November. Although the Republican governor opposed marijuana legalization as a social ailing, her administration’s arguments in courtroom centered on technical violations to the state structure.
The excessive courtroom sided with these arguments in a 4-1 choice, ruling that the measure — Modification A — would have violated the state’s requirement that constitutional amendments take care of only one topic.
“It’s clear that Modification A accommodates provisions embracing a minimum of three separate topics, every with distinct objects or functions,” Chief Justice Steven Jensen wrote within the majority opinion, which discovered leisure marijuana, medical marijuana and hemp every to be separate points.
South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem instigated the authorized struggle to strike down the modification that legalized leisure marijuana handed by voters in November. Right here, Noem speaks in Des Moines, Iowa, in July 2021.
Charlie Neibergall/AP
cover caption
toggle caption
Charlie Neibergall/AP
South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem instigated the authorized struggle to strike down the modification that legalized leisure marijuana handed by voters in November. Right here, Noem speaks in Des Moines, Iowa, in July 2021.
Charlie Neibergall/AP
About 54% of voters had accredited the constitutional modification final yr. However Freeway Patrol Superintendent Col. Rick Miller sued on Noem’s behalf. Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom additionally joined the lawsuit. The excessive courtroom dominated that the regulation enforcement officers didn’t have standing to sue, however as a result of Noem approved Miller’s swimsuit, they handled it as if Noem introduced the lawsuit herself.
Noem praised the choice, and famous that it could not change how she implements a separate, voter-passed regulation that legalizes medical marijuana. That regulation has already taken impact.
“South Dakota is a spot the place the rule of regulation and our Structure matter, and that is what right this moment’s choice is about,” she stated in an announcement. “We do issues proper — and the way we do issues — issues simply as a lot as what we’re doing.”
Pot legalization efforts will proceed within the state
The state Supreme Courtroom’s choice upheld a circuit judge’s ruling in February. Advocates for pot legalization appealed, arguing that the Supreme Courtroom ought to dismiss the authorized problem as a result of it overturned the desire of voters and dampened their future skill to enact legal guidelines via the poll field.
Matthew Schweich, the marketing campaign director for South Dakotans for Higher Marijuana Legal guidelines, known as the ruling “extraordinarily flawed” and reliant on “a disrespectful assumption that South Dakota voters have been intellectually incapable of understanding the initiative.”
“The courtroom has rejected frequent sense and as an alternative used a far-fetched authorized concept to overturn a regulation handed by over 225,000 South Dakota voters primarily based on no logical or evidentiary help,” he stated in an announcement.
Pot legalization is just not going away in South Dakota. Marijuana advocates are trying to bring recreational marijuana again to voters subsequent yr via a poll measure that will instruct the Legislature to legalize it. Lawmakers are also considering legalizing pot for adults within the upcoming legislative session.
Marijuana has become broadly accepted around the United States, with a Gallup Ballot final yr displaying 68% of Individuals favored legalization. South Dakota was amongst 4 states that month to approve leisure marijuana, together with New Jersey, Arizona and Montana. Fifteen states and the District of Columbia have performed so.
